We look after your interests

(+34) 93 626 47 75

Torres Sarrià, Carrer de Can Ràbia, 3-5, 4ª Planta BCN 08017

(+34) 91 794 19 82

Pº de la Castellana, 93 2nd floor MADRID 28046

Cluster Family Office Blog

The Cotton Test or Stress Test.

It has been criticised ad nauseam the stress test for Geithner. The reasoning was that a «litmus test» could only harm the US banking sector and its share prices: if the results showed a general pass, it would highlight the test’s futility and lack of rigour, and the markets would therefore punish this charade. If, on the other hand, the test singled out banks unable to withstand a worsening of the economic situation (which was both inevitable and imminent), these banks would plummet on the stock market, triggering extremely dangerous panic, amid fears of further Lehman Brothers-style collapses that could hardly be tolerated. But this prediction overlooked the fact that transparency also has a price – and a significant one at that.

The projected figures for the worsening of the situation, used in the stress test, are set out in the table below:


We note that, in the least negative scenario, the US economy is projected to contract by -2% in 2009 and to grow by 2.1% in 2010. In the most negative scenario, the economy is projected to contract by -3.3% and recover by 0.5%, respectively. Another variable is unemployment, which affects the general ability to service debts: between 8.4 and 8.9% in 2009 and 8.8 and 10.3% in 2010. We also see the projected fall in property prices (houses): between -14% and -22% for 2009, and between -4% and -7% for 2010.

Some also question the forecasts themselves, but in general the criticism centred on the futility and/or danger of publishing the results. Well, as things stand today (tomorrow is another matter), the effects of publishing the stress test are clear: greater transparency and confidence, which is translating into increased investor support for the major US banks. And that boost in confidence is a godsend for the world’s largest banking system.

As we mentioned last April in The Banking Crisis II and speculation in the US banking sector, the Obama’s bailout plan dispels the possibility of the major banks going bankrupt. The fact is that this possibility of Chapter 11 Until very recently, it was trading at the share prices of the most high-profile US companies. The credibility of that rescue plan, as well as the publication of the results of the litmus test credible and apparently rigorous (despite widespread criticism), have shed light on the future of the major North American banks.

Anything could happen in the markets over the coming months, but the systemic risk posed by the big banks and the spectre of Lehman Brothers are no longer a factor. Now it is «merely» a matter of fine-tuning the valuation of the goodwill and in any capital increases that may take place. However, the irrational and unfundamental value of the US banking system is proving to be the basis for the current share price, as we said last November. All it took was to dispel the spectre of bankruptcy for the shares to trade well above their intrinsic value. We do not see this phenomenon even in sectors as significant as the automotive industry.

The fact is, we are talking about something as vital as money – and the system that manages and creates it. These are such weighty matters that the mere guarantee of the survival of the major banks means that share prices, which previously reflected the risk of these institutions going bankrupt, have now been surpassed. The fundamental value, just like the size… no always It matters.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Security Notice

We have been made aware of phishing and spoofing attempts involving fraudulent email addresses and domains that closely resemble our official company communications. These unauthorized communications are not sent by our company and may falsely impersonate our employees or representatives.

Our company is not responsible for communications, requests, or transactions originating from fraudulent or unauthorized email addresses or domains. Please verify that all communications originate from our official email domain before responding or sharing any information.

If you receive a suspicious email claiming to be from our company, please do not respond, click any links, or provide any information. Contact us directly using the contact information published on this website to verify its authenticity.